Email marketing often gets a bad rep. Some say it’s “outdated,” while others claim it’s too much work for too little reward. If you’ve been on the fence about email marketing for your law firm, it’s time to rethink what you’ve heard. Successful campaigns rely on email marketing, which is alive and well and one of the most potent tools law firms have to attract and retain clients.

However, your email marketing strategy must consider and implement best practices; otherwise, your marketing efforts will not achieve the key performance indicators that measure success.

This blog debunks some of the most common email marketing myths. It breaks down the best practices for email marketing so you can confidently move forward, promote your legal services to new and existing clients, expand your subscriber list, and gain a competitive advantage.

What is Email Marketing for Lawyers?

Before we delve into the myths, let’s define email marketing. Email marketing is a digital marketing strategy that sends automated emails to a targeted audience to promote products, services, or relevant content, build relationships, and drive engagement. It’s a direct and cost-effective way for businesses to communicate with their audience, nurture leads, and convert them into customers.

Vital components of email marketing include:

• Email Newsletters: Regular updates sent to subscribers with valuable content, news, or promotions.
• Promotional Emails: Emails designed to promote specific products, services, or offers.
• Automated Campaigns: Pre-scheduled emails triggered by user actions, like welcome emails or abandoned cart reminders.
• Personalization: Tailoring emails to individual subscribers based on their preferences, behavior, or demographics.
• Analytics: You must measure the success of your email marketing efforts by tracking metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and conversions to measure success.

In short, email marketing is a versatile tool law firms can use for brand awareness, retention of existing clients, and lead generation for new clients.

Myth #1: Email Marketing Is Outdated

Think email marketing is old news? Think again. An ongoing email campaign remains one of the most effective digital marketing tools in 2025. Why? People still check their inboxes daily—occasionally even hourly. Studies show that email marketing boasts an average return on investment (ROI) of $36 for every $1 spent. Yes, you read that right. Few other marketing channels can deliver that kind of impact.

For law firms, email remains a viable avenue for staying top-of-mind with clients, offering valuable legal insights, and converting potential clients into consultations. It’s not outdated. It’s foundational.

Myth #2: Nobody Reads Marketing Emails Anymore

This myth simply doesn’t hold up to the data. According to MailChimp, the average email open rate for the legal industry is a solid 31.40%. While it’s true that inboxes can be crowded, crafting personalized messages and creating email campaigns for your target audience dramatically increases your chances of engagement.

For instance, segmenting your email list into categories—such as prospective clients, current clients, or referral partners—helps your message resonate. When people receive relevant content for their needs, they’re far more likely to open it, read it, and act on it.

Myth #3: Email Marketing Is Too Time-Consuming

Many law firms disregard email marketing, assuming it will consume too much of their already stretched schedules. Yet, with advancements in automation features, email marketing has never been easier or more efficient. An email marketing platform like Mailchimp, which has a free plan option, allows you to schedule emails in advance, create automated workflows, and even track performance metrics—saving you hours of manual work.

Even if you’re short on time, outsourcing email marketing to professionals can free you up while still maximizing results. Focus on running your firm while the experts ensure your campaigns work for you.

Myth #4: Email Marketing Won’t Help Me Get Legal Clients

One of the biggest misconceptions law firms have about email marketing campaigns is that they don’t attract clients. Email marketing isn’t just about sending newsletters; it’s about nurturing relationships and building trust over time. Consider the following statistics from OptinMonster.com:

• 52% of consumers purchased directly from an email in the last year, according to Marigold’s 2024 Consumer Trends Index.
• 18% of companies achieve email marketing ROI greater than $70 per $1 invested.
• Email outperformed banner ads and SMS marketing by 108% in 2023
• Email outperforms social media posts by 13% and social media ads by 11%

Law firms that want to capitalize on these stats might develop an email marketing strategy that sends monthly emails with FAQs about their practice areas, case studies, or success stories. This type of email content builds familiarity, positions law firms as trusted authorities, and encourages potential clients to become retained clients by reaching out when they need representation.

Need More Reasons to Send Emails? More Benefits of Email Marketing for Law Firms

Still not convinced about the effectiveness of a strategic email campaign? Here’s a quick recap of why email marketing campaigns should be an essential part of your strategy:

• Cost-Effective: Email marketing gives you more bang for your buck than traditional advertising.
• Targeted Audience Reach: Deliver the right message to the right people with list segmentation and personalized content.
• High ROI: Statistics prove that email marketing is one of the most profitable marketing channels.
• Automated Efficiency: Email service providers make scaling your efforts easy without increasing your workload.

Top Features of An Effective Email

An effective email template combines strategy, creativity, and attention to detail. With inboxes overflowing and competition for attention growing, tailoring your emails to stand out is crucial. Here are the top features that ensure your email hits the mark:

1. 1. Short Subject Lines

Your goal is to attract the reader’s attention with short subject lines — the first thing they see. Avoid vague or overly generic phrases. Instead, create subject lines that spark curiosity, provide value, or highlight urgency. For example, “Does Your Website Domain Authority Matter?”

1. 2. Engaging and Relevant Content

Once you’ve hooked your audience with the subject line, the email’s content must deliver on its promise. Create content that resonates with your subscribers by understanding their preferences, challenges, and interests. Keep your message clear and concise; no one wants to wade through giant blocks of text. Use a friendly yet professional tone and always include a clear call-to-action (CTA) guiding readers on the next step.

1. 3. Personalized to Engage Readers

Your subscribers can easily ignore generic emails. To compel them to keep reading, personalize your emails by using recipients’ names and tailoring content based on their past actions or interests. When you make your emails feel relevant on an individual level, you’re more likely to capture and hold your subscribers’ attention.

1. 4. Sent to a Clean Contact List

A well-maintained list helps your emails reach the right audience. Remove inactive subscribers regularly and avoid purchasing an email list at all costs. The goal of your email newsletters is to communicate with readers who genuinely want to hear from you, not to uninterested recipients. Quality always beats quantity when it comes to your audience.

1. 5. Avoids Spam Filters

No matter how good your email looks, it won’t matter if it gets buried in the spam folder. To avoid this, avoid spam-triggering words like “free” or “act now” in your subject line and body text. Confirm that all recipients have opted in to receive your emails, and use tools to test your email content against spam filters before hitting “send.”

Effective emails don’t just happen—they result from thoughtful planning. By focusing on the subject line, creating content that connects, and maintaining a clean email list, you’ll be well on your way to building strong relationships with your email subscribers.

Email Marketing Services

Email marketing services like Mailchimp help law firms connect meaningfully with their ideal clients, turning potential leads into signed cases. These services help you send emails by leveraging tools and features that streamline the process of creating, sending, and managing email campaigns.

Email marketing software is at the core of email marketing services. This software offers a centralized platform where users can design visually appealing emails, segment their audience, automate drip campaigns, and track performance metrics like open rates and conversions. Many email providers integrate seamlessly with these platforms, facilitating smooth delivery and reducing the chances of messages landing in spam folders.

A significant advantage of modern email marketing solutions is their focus on reaching mobile users. With more people accessing emails on smartphones and tablets, email marketing solutions optimize campaigns for mobile accessibility. Responsive templates adjust emails to fit any screen size, enhancing user experience and increasing the likelihood of engagement.

Additionally, email marketing software allows law firms to customize their outreach. You can tailor your content based on specific demographics, preferences, or behavior through audience segmentation. This personalization makes recipients feel valued, increasing their connection to your law firm’s brand.

Ultimately, email marketing software provides an efficient, scalable way for your law firm to nurture relationships with current clients and win over future clients. Whether you’re sending newsletters, promotions, or updates, email marketing solutions send your messages to the right people at the right time while aligning with today’s digital landscape.

FAQs About Law Firm Email Marketing

1. How can an email marketing strategy support my SEO strategy?

Email marketing and SEO may seem unrelated, but they work hand-in-hand to increase your online visibility. By sending out newsletters or updates, you can share links to your blogs, landing pages, or case studies, driving traffic back to your website. More traffic improves search engine rankings, showing your law firm’s website as a credible and authoritative source. Additionally, well-crafted emails can encourage recipients to leave online reviews, further enhancing local search rankings.

2. Will email campaigns help increase website traffic for my law firm?

Yes. By including links to valuable resources, consultations, or service offerings, you can guide recipients directly to your website. Regularly sharing relevant content through email keeps your audience engaged and more likely to visit your site for more information. This consistent flow of visitors signals search engines that your website is active and engaging, adding even more value to your online presence.

3. Can I use email marketing campaigns to promote my law firm’s landing pages?

Absolutely. Landing pages help convert potential clients, and email campaigns are ideal for promoting them. By creating targeted emails that include calls to action (CTAs) linking to your landing pages, you can direct readers to schedule consultations, download resources, or sign up for newsletters. Many email tools also allow you to track how recipients interact with these links so you can refine your messaging for better results.

4. What features should law firms look for in most email providers?

When choosing an email provider, prioritize features that align with your goals. Look for email providers that offer automation tools for follow-ups, segmentation options for targeted outreach, and analytics to measure campaign effectiveness. Mobile optimization is another must-have, giving emails a professional look across all devices. Since law firms must have data security, choose a provider known for strong encryption and compliance with privacy regulations.

5. How does email marketing compare to social media for client engagement? 

Email marketing offers a more direct and personalized approach compared to social media. While platforms like LinkedIn and Facebook build awareness, emails nurture deeper relationships by enabling law firms to send tailored content directly to prospective clients’ inboxes, keeping your services top of mind. It also drives traffic to assets like landing pages or your website, creating opportunities for conversions in ways that social media often can’t match.

Are You an Aggressive, Growth-Minded Attorney? Let Law Firm Marketing Pros Offer Email Marketing Solutions While You Focus on What You Do Best

Don’t buy into the myths holding your law firm back. Whether reconnecting with past clients, generating new leads, or maintaining relationships with referral partners, maintaining an email list and regular contact with your subscribers is more important than ever.

Would you rather represent clients than oversee drip campaigns and manage email addresses? We understand.

At Law Firm Marketing Pros, we partner with ambitious attorneys seeking more cases by getting their digital marketing right. Result: Make more money, reclaim valuable time, and focus on what matters most.

Are you curious about how email marketing, when implemented in conjunction with an effective digital law firm marketing strategy, can give your law firm a competitive edge?

Contact Partner and Co-Founder Josh Konigsberg, author of Law Firm Digital Marketing Made Easy: The Only Book You’ll Ever Need to Become a Best-Known Attorney , to schedule a free 15-minute client accelerator call at (561) 948-5001 or complete our online form.

Though brief, this call dives deep into your strategy. Josh will then prepare a complimentary digital marketing brief packed with 25-35 pages of value that drives qualified clients directly to your practice.

Copyright © 2025. Law Firm Marketing Pros. All rights reserved.

This blog is not intended to be legal advice for a lawyer or law practice. No special relationship or privilege exists between you and the Blog and/or its owners, Law Firm Marketing Pros, or its Affiliates (“LFMP”). LFMP IS NOT A LAW FIRM, and THE AUTHOR IS NOT AN ATTORNEY. You will be representing yourself and your law practice in any legal matter you undertake or any Client you represent as a result of your use of the information provided in the Blog, including any Services offered through the Blog and content available on the Site the Blog is published on and in all other matters relating to you and your businesses. This Blog may provide audio-video content, referenced articles, newsletters, and other content for informational purposes only. In the process of providing this information, the Blog is engaged in the publication of information regarding business and management issues that may be commonly encountered by law firms. This blog is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. This Blog does not review any of your answers to questions for sufficiency, provide legal advice, or analyze applicable law and apply it to your specific requirements. Accordingly, if you need legal advice for a specific issue, you are advised to seek the advice of your local, state, and/or national Bar Association.

Law Firm Marketing Pros
250 S. Central Blvd, Suite 100-A
Jupiter, FL 33458
(561) 948-5001
https://lawfirmmarketingpros.com/